The 1796 house at 20 Union Street was built for the whaling captain Lester Beebe. In 1876 it was renovated by the New York architect Stephen B. French, and it was later known as the "summer White House" of President Chester A. Arthur. Its gardens run from Jefferson Street through to Union. After a full renovation and redesign by Steven Gambrel, it changed hands on September 5 for $11.8 million, 27east reported. The house has 5,900 square feet, so the price works out to about $2,000 a foot.
That figure is a useful yardstick for the rest of this year's reported Sag Harbor sales. Put them side by side on a per-foot basis and they follow one pattern. In 2026, buyers in and around the village paid the most when the seller had already taken on the design and building work. They paid much less for plans, for permits and for extra square footage. That includes waterfront square footage a short walk from Main Street.
A renovated house and a new one set the top of the village
The other high mark this year came from a site with a long local history. 100 Glover Street was part of the Cilli family farm, which ran as a working dairy until the family sold the herd in the 1970s. In 2022 the early-1920s house, the barn and four other structures were approved for demolition to make way for a two-lot subdivision. One of the new homes, a five-bedroom farmhouse by DeMarco Development with design by Craft Modern, sold for $13 million as of September 24, according to 27east. It has 4,960 square feet on 0.62 acres and borders 9 acres of preserve on two sides. That comes to roughly $2,620 a foot, the highest figure among the sales covered here. The listing side told 27east the home "has set a new bar in the village."
The two houses have little in common on paper. One is an 18th-century house with a presidential story behind it, and the other is new construction on old dairy land that went to market before it was complete. In both cases the design and building work were the seller's responsibility, not the buyer's. At about $2,000 and $2,620 a foot, they are the two top numbers in this set of sales.
A permit in hand added little to the price
On Brush Neck, between the Big Narrows and the Small Narrows, 154 Redwood Road is a 0.72-acre lot facing west across Sag Harbor Cove. It has 85 feet of private shoreline, a dock, and permits in place for a house designed by Blaze Makoid. The lot can hold a residence of up to 6,000 square feet. 27east described it as "shovel-ready", and the deal closed on October 26 for $5.38 million. In 2021 the same property traded for $5.28 million. Five years later, with permits in hand at the time of sale, the price was less than 2 percent higher.
A few blocks away, 98 Bay Street shows the same thing with a house on the lot. The early-1900s house has 4,500 square feet, four bedrooms, a heated gunite pool and a guesthouse. It came to market toward the end of 2024 and was last asking $5.95 million in December, The Real Deal reported. It sold this year for $5.65 million, which The Real Deal put at $1,255 a foot for the main house. During the sale, architects drew plans for possible updates and the listing team secured planning permissions for the work.
Both sellers handed a buyer an approved next step. The sale prices suggest buyers valued that step at close to nothing. For these buyers, an approved plan was still a project to carry out, and the per-foot figures were priced that way.
Size sold at a discount, even on the water
Residence B at 2 West Water Street is the case that tests the pattern hardest. It is one of three homes in a development Jay Bialsky completed in 2023, set directly on Sag Harbor Cove with a private beach and a deep-water marina, a short walk from Main Street. It has 11,723 square feet with eight bedrooms. It is new, finished and on the water. It sold in late September for $12.2 million, Behind the Hedges reported, after about seven months on the shared listing. It had most recently been asking $15.5 million and at one point $24.95 million.
At about $1,040 a foot, it brought the lowest per-foot price of any finished house here, while being the only one with its own marina. The buyer's side described a very specific purchase to Behind the Hedges: a buyer who wanted to be on the water, keep a boat at the door and still walk into the village for dinner. That buyer paid for that combination of water, boat access and a walk to dinner, and the extra thousands of square feet added comparatively little.
Read beside 20 Union and 100 Glover, the West Water sale suggests that this year in Sag Harbor, buyers seem to have priced the finished rooms they would actually use. They did not price every foot the plans contained.
The five sales, side by side
| Address | What sold | Reported price | Size | Approx. per foot |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100 Glover Street | New farmhouse on former Cilli dairy land, listed precompletion, sold as of Sept. 24 | $13,000,000 | 4,960 sq ft | $2,620 |
| 20 Union Street | 1796 house, fully renovated by Steven Gambrel, sold Sept. 5 | $11,800,000 | 5,900 sq ft | $2,000 |
| 98 Bay Street | Early-1900s house with guesthouse, plans and permissions drawn | $5,650,000 | 4,500 sq ft | $1,255 |
| 2 West Water Street, Residence B | 2023 waterfront townhome with marina, sold late September | $12,200,000 | 11,723 sq ft | $1,040 |
| 154 Redwood Road | Waterfront lot with dock and permits, closed Oct. 26 | $5,380,000 | 0.72 acres | Lot sale |
The per-foot figures for Glover, Union and West Water are simple division of the reported price by the reported size. The 98 Bay figure is The Real Deal's. These are five reported sales, not a statistical series, and each house has features a spreadsheet does not capture. Still, the ranking runs in the same direction every time.
The wider East End points the same way
Sag Harbor's sales took place in a tighter Hamptons market. In the third quarter of 2026, the Hamptons recorded 385 single-family and condo closings, 8.6 percent fewer than in the third quarter of 2025. The 973 listings at quarter's end were 22.5 percent below a year earlier, and the median price of $1.995 million was about 5 percent lower than in the third quarter of 2025. Those are Miller Samuel figures as summarized by Long Island Business News. With fewer sales and fewer listings, buyers had more time to separate one house from another.
Agents across the East End described the same sorting in a September roundtable in Behind the Hedges. Marilyn Clark said turnkey properties remain one of buyers' biggest priorities and that "very few people want to take on a major renovation project." Margot Reutter said buyers may give ground on finishes but are "much less willing to budge" on location, setting, quality of construction and privacy. In an October roundtable in the same publication, agents said buyers had grown more cautious about paying premiums and less willing to chase listings, and that sellers who tested the market in spring and summer might need to reset expectations.
In Sag Harbor the same sorting ran through a single village, where a house on Union Street and a lot on Redwood Road share one market and drew very different prices per foot.
How a buyer comparing villages can read this
A buyer weighing Sag Harbor against Bridgehampton, North Haven or East Hampton is probably comparing asking prices. These sales suggest asking prices in the village were a weak guide this year. The two houses here with a reported last asking price, on Bay Street and West Water Street, both sold below it, and the lot with permits sold within a rounding error of its 2021 price. The more reliable signal was whether the seller had already done the work.
For a buyer, a house that still needs work, even one with permits in place, is likely to trade at a real discount to a finished house in the same village. The approvals that come with it are unlikely to add much to its price. For a seller holding an older house, the 2026 sales point toward finishing the work or pricing the house as a project. They do not point toward marketing the drawings. Our Sag Harbor neighborhood page and market reports carry the broader picture, and a private valuation can place a specific house within this range.
FAQ
Is waterfront still the top tier in Sag Harbor? In this year's reported sales, the waterfront townhome at 2 West Water Street brought about $1,040 a foot. The renovated house on Union Street and the new house on Glover Street brought roughly $2,000 and $2,620. On these five sales, being on the water did not outrank having the work done.
Did a shovel-ready lot sell at a premium? 154 Redwood Road came with a dock and permits for a Blaze Makoid house. It sold for $5.38 million in October 2026, against $5.28 million in 2021.
How did the overall Hamptons market move this year? In the third quarter of 2026, closings were down 8.6 percent from a year earlier, listings were down 22.5 percent, and the median was $1.995 million, per Miller Samuel figures reported by Long Island Business News.
If you're weighing a finished Sag Harbor house against one that still needs work, or deciding how to bring an older village house to market, we're glad to talk it through. Schedule a private consultation with Jennifer Friedberg.